1 LLR 63
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 63. Source pages 63–65 (PDF pages 73–75). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1873.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
63 M. T. WORRELL and G. S. RUSSWURM , Appel- lants , vs. R. S. MCGILL , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1873.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . An error committed by a party in the execution of a deed , where it does not appear to have been done with a fraudulent design , will not amount to fraud , nor will it vitiate the instrument. This is a case sent up to the Supreme Court on appeal from the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions , Mont- serrado County . Upon careful review of the records in this case the court cannot discover the existence of fraud in either of the defendants in the court below ( appellants ) . The defendant (now one of the appellants ) , G. S. Russwurm , appears to have acted in good faith when he executed the deed to M. T. Worrell , and the error in transferring his right to the property in dispute by metes and bounds , by his own showing , which was admitted as evidence in the court below , was an error of fact, with no intention of fraud , and in this sense it appears M. T. Worrell re- ceived the said transfer . The court , however , discovers from the record that the court below erred in founding its judgment or decree upon evidence which said court had ruled out as inadmissible . This is clearly contrary to both law and equity , and as a matter of course vitiates the decree of the court below . The court admits that a co - tenant cannot sell by metes and bounds his right and title in an estate , unless partition be made ; and in this respect Russwurm erred . Nevertheless , taking his , Russ- wurm's , written explanation admitted by the court below , equity demands that all his interest and title in the property , lot 325 in Monrovia , ought to be vested in Moore T. Worrell , for although the deed from Russwurm to Worrell conveyed more than he had a legal right to con- vey , this does not invalidate the deed , but it is a good 64 and valid conveyance of the amount of interest Russ- wurm really possessed in the said lot No. 325 . Therefore the court adjudges that the decree of the lower court be reversed , and the deed executed by G. S. Russwurm to Moore T. Worrell is hereby decreed to be a good and valid conveyance to the said Moore T. Worrell of all the right, title and interest the said G. S. Russwurm possessed in the said lot number three hundred and twenty- five in the city of Monrovia , Republic of Liberia ; the appellee to pay all costs . CHARLES BATAM , Appellant , vs. LILES , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1873. ] EDWARD Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County . When a case has been removed upon a change of venue , the court from which the case is removed loses its jurisdiction over the same by the very act itself. This is a ruling upon the returns of the judge , D. F. Smith , setting forth his reasons for not proceeding to the trial of the case of Charles Batam vs. Edward Liles . The court is of the opinion that the plaintiff in the court below was rather precipitate in the entering of his case de novo before he had secured the judgment of the court of Maryland County , to which the case was removed . And he was in error when he assumed to have had the right to withdraw the original action , by giving such notice to the court of Grand Bassa County , after it had been removed upon a change of venue , and when really , or rather legally , there was no case of Charles Batam vs. Edward Liles then existing in said court of Grand Bassa. County . For it is very obvious when a case has been removed upon a change of venue , the court from which the case is removed loses its jurisdiction over the same by the very act itself . 65 However , the defendant, Edward Liles , having filed in court his answer to the plaintiff, Charles Batam's , complaint , the defendant is therefore bound by the same to the extent of the legal right of the plaintiff to recover against him. Upon the examination of the returns of Judge D. F. Smith , it seems that his objection offered for not pro- ceeding with the case was based upon several grounds , one of which this court regards as being well founded : that is , the judge had denied the defendant the privilege of a change of venue , believing it was his duty to do so ; therefore he held that he could not , in justice to all parties , force him , the defendant, to trial after having thus denied him this privilege . It was certainly the privilege of the defendant equally as legal as that of the plaintiff to renew his action after a non-suit, and it ought not to have been denied him . However, the court says and commands that the said Judge D. F. Smith of the aforesaid court of Grand Bassa County proceed to exercise jurisdiction over said case , securing to both parties, however , all the privileges given them by law. The clerk of this court is hereby com- manded to forward a copy of this mandate to Judge D. F. Smith of the Court of Quarter Sessions of Grand Bassa County .
Selected judicial document
Worrell et al. v. McGill
Supreme Court of Liberia