1 LLR 525
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 525. Source pages 525–533 (PDF pages 535–543). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1892. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
525 T. L. WARNER , Appellant , vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . Conspiracy . [January Term , A. D. 1892. ] Before His Honor C. L. Parsons , Chief Justice , and the Honorable Associate Justices . MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL . The Republic of Liberia, appellee in the above entitled cause , by Henry W. Grimes , Attorney General of said Republic , respect- fully motions this honorable court to dismiss this case for the following reasons : First , because there is a provision made by the laws of said Republic for criminal cases to be brought to this honorable court by appeal . Second, and also because T. L. Warner , the appellee in this case , does not appear, from the record filed in this case , to have tendered a bill of exceptions and prayed an appeal in the court below . Third , and also because the bond filed in this case as appellee's bond is not such a bond as the law requires , as it does not bind appellant to indemnify the appellee from all injuries arising from the appeal and to comply with the judgment of this honorable court , or any other to which said case may be removed . Fourth, and also because the record in this case is imperfect , as no writ of arrest or other process appears in said record . Respectfully submitted, THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee , By HY . W. GRIMES , Atty . Genl . R. L. COURT'S RULING . The court here says , that the question raised in the motion of the Attorney General to dismiss the case has had its considera- tion , and the court takes pleasure in further saying that there are involved in the motion questions which have been frequently before it, and which were the subject of discussion twenty -five years ago. Coming directly to the merits of the motion , however , in regard to the right to appeal upon a bill of exceptions in criminal cases , we do not hesitate to say that it is our duty to consider what was the intention of the framers of the Constitution , by incorporating those acts of the Commonwealth with the laws of the Republic of Liberia. In noticing these , together with the Constitution of the Republic of Liberia , we find in the idea of the 526 Constitution that the right of appeal in civil and criminal cases is one of the fundamental prerogatives upon which the liberty of the people stands. To do away with this idea would be to set aside the dearest provision of the fathers , made in the bulwark of our national fabric , which serves as a preventive against oppres- sion and a security to the enjoyment of civil liberty ; without which , the people must become dwarfed in manhood and enter- prise , and as a consequence energy, thrift , enterprise and noble aspirations will cease to exist and flourish under our national flag, and will seek some other land for encouragement and pro- tection . The framers of the Constitution , knowing this , and con- sidering our situation , disadvantages , and our limited knowledge of law and of political government at that time , sought to make our national road to greatness plain and easy , and to be under- stood by the whole people ; hence , by the Constitution , they clothed the Supreme Court with appellate jurisdiction in all cases of appeal . The language by which the right of appeal to the Supreme Court is secured may not be mistaken by the simplest mind , if it be free from prejudice , hatred or influence of bribery . And it is also very clear that the fathers , in making the Statute of Appeals , intended it as the proper step by which both civil and criminal cases of appeal should find their way to the Supreme Court . This con- clusion we come to from the fact that from the earliest existence of Liberia, both lawmakers under the authority of the Common- wealth and lawmakers under the Constitution of the Republic of Liberia, who knew best their intention in constructing the law, in their practice as lawyers before the courts , in both civil and criminal cases of appeal , followed the direction of the Statute of Appeal , to which we alluded . It is therefore the opinion of this court that appeals in criminal cases lie to the Supreme Court upon bills of exceptions , and a denial of the right would be gross injustice . It is scarcely necessary for us to say that when several parties are indicted in one indictment they may make common defence , or elect to be tried separately ; and if the trial be joint , all should join in the plea or defence , and in case an appeal be prayed , the bill of exceptions should embrace the names of all the parties appealing , however many there may be. On inspecting the record. in this case we find a bill of exceptions purporting to be tendered by one F. J. Payne alone , thereby creating a non-joinder of the appellants in this case . This irregularity is not cured by the signature of the judge to said bill of exceptions . Regularly a bill of exceptions should be so construed as to come within the purview of the statute , and therefore should in all of its parts set forth with 527 certainty the names of the parties thereto . This court is therefore of opinion that this point raised in the motion is of legal foundation . This court therefore adjudges that the appeal be dismissed, and hereby directs that the clerk of this court make known the same to the court from which the appeal was taken . Supreme Court, January Term, 1892 . J. W. TOLES , Appellant , vs. I. C. DICKINSON , Appellee . Fraud. [January Term , A. D. 1892.] Before His Honor C. L. Parsons , Chief Justice , and the Honorable Associate Justices . MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL . The appellee , I. C. Dickinson , respectfully motions the honor- able the Supreme Court to dismiss the above entitled cause and rule the appellant to costs , because the appellant has not brought up his appeal in the manner and form required by law and the rule and practice of this honorable court , in this , that at the last term of this honorable court , when this case was called for trial , upon the report of the marshal it appeared that the appellant had neglected to have appellee summoned into this court , nor was the appellee so summoned until the 28th day of December in the year 1891 , more than one year after the case had been docketed , as will appear by the record of this honorable court and by the said summons . Wherefore appellee prays that this case be dismissed and the appellant ordered to pay the costs . Respectfully submitted , I. C. DICKINSON , Appellee , By ARTHUR BARCLAY , Attorney and Counsellor at Law . COURT'S RULING . When an appeal has been taken , nothing ought to prevent the investigation of the same but the want of proper jurisdiction . The case being an appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County , when it was called up Coun- sellor Haynes , for the appellant , requested the court to assign the case to some other day. Counsellor Barclay , for the appellee , informed the court that he was the attorney for the appellee in the court below and had not been duly summoned, neither had his 528 client , and he requested the court to lay it over until the next session. After some remarks , it being a case of equity , the court ordered the case to be continued . The court , however , says that rights which neither of the parties had within the term of the court at which the case was docketed to be tried , could upon any principle of law or method of reason- ing accrue to him after the term in which the case was brought up to be heard , because of the continuation of the same . For it is very obvious that if the appellant neglected to summon the appellee to appear at the court in the term in which the case was to be reviewed , the court could take no jurisdiction over the person of the appellee , for it is the notice that gives the court jurisdiction . Therefore the court says that no notice served after the term of which the case was brought up for hearing could be substituted for the one which ought to have been given in the legal term of the court in which it was entered to be examined , nor could such a notice have any legal effect . Therefore the court says the case is hereby dismissed , and the clerk of this court ordered to send down to the court below , in which the case was originally tried , a notice of the doings of this court . Supreme Court , January Term, 1892 . J. B. C. ROYE , Appellant , vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . Murder. [January Term , A. D. 1892.] COURT'S RULING ON MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL . Statutes must be strictly construed as to intention and effects , therefore when any statute or part of it conflicts with the words , meaning and spirit of any constitutional provision , because of it , want of applicability to the case in which it is desired to be applied , such statute , or such part of it affected by the constitutional pro- vision , can have no legal bearing in such a case . The Constitu- tion, being the greatest and highest law , predominates , or destroys the power and effect of the statute or any part of it which con- flicts with any of its provisions in that particular case ; therefore we say, the Constitution forbids the taking of bail in capital offences , which entirely excludes the idea of an appeal bond of indemnification , or any other bond , as it would be without author- 529 ity, and in violation of the Constitution . Our statute on appeal provides for both civil and criminal cases ; in its use and applica- tion it must be reasonably construed to meet the nature of the case under its direction . Hence we say the second plea in the motion is insufficient . In regard to the third plea , the court is of the opinion that a writ in the hands of the County Attorney which has not been returned to the court is not within the legal embraces of the court , whether such a writ be issued by the Justice of the Peace sending up the case for trial , or by the court from which the appeal was taken. Therefore the court says , the clerk was only bound to give a true copy of the record and proceedings of the case before the court . And this court , to make its position more plain as to this last plea in the motion that is before it , does say that a court , according to the Statutes of Liberia, is composed of the judge , clerk , and its seal . Hence the County Attorney is no part of the court proper ; he is only an attorney , or prosecutor for the county. The court further says the necessity of issuing a writ of arrest against a felon already apprehended and held in custody for trial, does not exist. His subsequent indictment is sufficient to warrant an arraignment and trial. Therefore the court does not sustain the motion to dismiss the case . Supreme Court , February , 1892 . COURT'S RULING ON MOTION TO COMPEL ISSUE OF WRIT OF ERROR . In the matter of the petition of C. B. Reeves , attorney below for Henry More, tried and convicted at the December term of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County , 1896 , for a writ of error , by him handed to this court , praying an order for the issue of said writ . The matter has been considered , and while it is the desire of this court to render its aid in the furtherance of justice , yet it does not feel warranted in setting aside its established rules . By Rule 26 a writ of error is obtainable, and is to be issued by the clerk whenever errors are assigned under its provisions ; one of the requirements being that the appellant or applicant shall have attached to said assignment of errors , the certificate of one coun- sellor of this court , or one attorney of any of the country courts , certifying that in the opinion of said counsellor or attorney real errors are assigned therein . 530 This rule does not bear an interpretation that can be met by the certificate of the petitioner in this case , although he may be a member of the bar of this county . As parties are unconsciously prejudiced to their own opinions and views , the rule contemplates that a disinterested counsellor or attorney shall certify that real errors exist . In this petition the petitioner assigns the errors, hence he should have procured the certificate of a counsellor or attorney , certifying that there are errors , committed or apparent , to warrant the issue of the writ required . This not appearing , the court cannot sustain the motion without setting aside its rules . The motion is therefore dismissed. Supreme Court , January Term, 1897 . MOTION TO DISBAR A COUNSELLOR . Monrovia , Jan. 11th , 1898 . To the Honorable Z. B. Roberts , Chief Justice , and the Honorable Associates R. B. Richardson and J. J. Dossen : The undersigned counsellors of the Supreme Court of this Repub- lic respectfully showeth to this honorable court that for a long period of time Francis J. Payne , one of the counsellors of this court , has conducted himself in a reprehensible manner , first by being habitually intoxicated , and secondly by committing infrac- tion of the peace by using profane and obscene language in the public streets , to the disturbance of good citizens of this com- munity , and is habitually being guilty of conduct unbecoming a gentleman and a member of this honorable court . We therefore , as counsellors of this honorable court , bring these charges , requesting that he may be suspended from all the privi- leges of a member of this bar ; he not even being licensed as an attorney . And this your petitioners will ever pray . Respectfully submitted , F. E. R. JOHNSON , T. W. HAYNES , COURT'S RULING . Counsellors at Law . In the matter of the petition of counsellors F. E. R. Johnson and T. W. Haynes , brought before this court at its present ses- sion , in which the petitioners petitioned the court to suspend Counsellor Francis J. Payne from all the privileges of a member of this bar , for the following reasons , to wit : First , for being habitu- 531 ally intoxicated ; and secondly, for committing infractions of the peace by using profane and obscene language in the public streets , to the disturbance of the good citizens of this community , and also being guilty of habitual conduct unbecoming a gentleman and member of this honorable court . The matter being one in which the right of a member of this bar to practise before it is the only point at issue , this court exer- cises original jurisdiction , and having heard the evidence and the arguments on the part of the prosecution and defence , will now proceed to give decision in the matter . By reference to the petition now under consideration , we find the grounds upon which the petition is predicated , as indicated. above , are "habitual intoxication , infraction of the peace by using profane and obscene language in the public streets , and habitual conduct unbecoming a gentleman and member of this honorable court ." What conduct is referred to as "unbecoming a gentle- man and member of this honorable court ," is not stated and set forth in the petition . The court is therefore bound to deal with those charges only which are clearly , distinctly and specifically set out in the petition ; and it will confine itself to the considera- tion of that portion of the petition only . To ascertain what acts or offences which , if committed by a member of the bar, will render him liable to be disbarred or suspended , recourse must be had to the laws of the country , and as in all other cases , so here, are we bound to confine ourselves to the principles of these laws and must strictly keep within the purview of them . The Statute of Liberia pertaining to attorneys , found on the 129th page , Art . 9, Sec. 1 , of the Revised Statute , empowers the several courts of Liberia with the right to withdraw the license of any regularly licensed attorney whenever he should be guilty of indecorous lan- guage, either toward the court or jury . By a subsequent act of the Legislature of Liberia, passed by limitation , January 28th , 1878 , the right and power to disbar or suspend members of the bar for the cause of contempt, was withdrawn from the inferior courts and conferred solely upon the Supreme Court of Liberia. (Act of Legislature , 1877-78 , p. 11 , sec . 1. ) The right , there- fore , to disbar , suspend or otherwise deprive a member of the bar from the enjoyment of the privileges and rights of a lawyer , on the ground of contempt, is a right which under the statutes of Liberia can only be exercised by the Supreme Court of Liberia. But it is clear and obvious that the above cited act relates to con- tempt only . There are other cases , however , which will warrant a court to disbar or suspend members of its bar , and it is to this 532 class of offences that the petition under consideration strictly relates . We shall now proceed to notice some of the causes . An attempt to make an opposing attorney drunk in order to obtain an advan- tage of him in the trial of a cause , is good ground for striking an attorney from the roll. (U. S. Digest , Vol . III , p . 85. ) So too , where an attorney obtains money by false representations relative to matters entrusted to him in that capacity. (Idem .) When an attorney has been prosecuted by an indictment or information , and has confessed guilt , or been found guilty by a jury , the courts in which he practised have the power , upon his guilt thus appear- ing , to strike his name from the roll of attorneys . (Idem .) It does not appear from the petition before us, nor from the evidence produced , nor was it maintained by the counsellor for the prosecution in his arguments , that the improper conduct alleged against Counsellor Payne had at any time subjected him to prosecution and conviction upon a bill of indictment or informa- tion, for an infamous offence . Nor does it appear that he has been guilty of committing any offence above the degree of petty infraction of the peace . While we admit , without the slightest hesitancy, that habitual intoxication and the use of profane and obscene language is indeed against the morals of good society , and that such conduct may be made the subject of petty prosecution , yet we are inclined to the opinion that such conduct does not constitute an offence suffi- ciently grave and cogent in its nature , to subject one to such punishment as would disqualify him to be a member of the bar . Mere discreditable acts , if not infamous , and not connected with an attorney's duties, will not give the court the right to strike him from the roll . ( U. S. Digest , Vol . III , p. 85 ; I Bouvier's Law Dict. p. 34 : "Disbar .") Allusion is made in the petition to the fact that Counsellor Payne has failed to renew his license as an attorney , and therefore should be suspended from the privileges of the bar . This fact having been admitted by him , we shall proceed to see how far it will operate against him as a member of the bar . It is an unques- tionable fact that no lawyer can be admitted to practice before any court of this Republic before paying into the public treasury the annual tax imposed by law for the privilege , and obtaining a license from the officer designated by law, granting him the right to plead and implead before the several courts of the Republic . The rule governing the formal requisites of the license of an attorney having already been copiously laid down by this court 533 in the case of Reginald A. Sherman against Republic of Liberia, decided by this court at its January term , A. D. 1881 , we deem it unnecessary to enter into a lengthy discussion on this point . While the court is of the opinion that Counsellor Francis J. Payne is not entitled to practise before this or any other court of the Republic before he has renewed his license as an attorney by paying into the public treasury the annual tax fee required by law , still this court does not find him guilty of an offence suffi- cient in law to disbar or suspend him from the roll as a member of this bar . For the foregoing reasons the court dismisses the petition , without costs . Supreme Court , January Term , 1898 . REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Appellant , vs. DONNER JUNGST , Appellee . Violation of Revenue Laws . [January Term , A. D. 1907.] COURT'S RULING ON MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL . At the call of this case for trial , the appellee submitted to this court a motion to dismiss the cause , because the appellant had failed to give bond in taking the appeal , as required by law. In this case the Republic of Liberia was the plaintiff below , prose- cuting for an alleged violation of her revenue laws . This motion has had the careful consideration of this court , and after carefully examining the principles involved , the court has come to the following conclusions : To require bond of the Repub- lic, and on failure , to subject her to attachment , arrest , etc. , as private individuals , would tend to endless confusion , first , because the Legislature has not as yet made any law requiring bail in such prosecutions , whether civil or criminal ; it has only provided for suits in actions of contract against the Government . For this reason the State is not bound by the rules of practice laid down for private prosecutors . Law is based upon reason , and the requirement of bail is to protect litigant parties against escape , etc. Governments can never escape , hence the reason of this law, to protect against escape , ceases to exist . Second , this court further says , the present laws requiring bail , and subjecting those neglecting to comply therewith , to arrest , execution , etc. , in no way apply to the Government . The motion is therefore not sus- tained and this court orders that the trial proceed .
Selected judicial document
Warner v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia