1 LLR 472
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 472. Source pages 472–476 (PDF pages 482–486). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1906. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
472 BEGBAH , alias PETER , Appellant , vs. REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1906. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas, Montserrado County . Murder . This is a case in which appellant Begbah was indicted for the murder of one Dumah , both of whom are inhabit- ants of Krootown , Monrovia . At the September term , 1904 , of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas of Montserrado County , he was tried , convicted , and sentenced to be executed . Appellant , by his attorney , motioned the court to set aside the verdict and to grant him a new trial , because to his mind the verdict was manifestly against the law and evidence in the case . Upon the court refusing to grant the motion , appellant excepted and prayed an appeal to the Supreme Court. In reviewing the case this court has carefully con- sidered the evidence to enable it to decide whether the facts as laid in the indictment were sustained at the trial below . Nothing is or can be dearer to man than his life , hence no other man nor a legal tribunal has the right to dispossess one of life , except by due process of law backed by unequivocal evidence . For this potent reason this court , the dernier ressort of justice , is slow and careful in weighing facts and evidence to the disposses- sing of man of that life not given by man but given by God. In this case , the court finds that there were employed seven witnesses on the part of the State , namely , N. H. Gibson , J. R. Allison , Africa and Willitoe Tobey , Dr. H. C. Faulkner, C. D. B. King and Iverson Thompson ; on the part of the prisoner , appellant , one , namely , Johnson . By a careful examination of the evidence deposed , the 473 court finds the depositions of the witnesses N. H. Gibson , J. R. Allison , Africa and Willitoe Tobey in substance to be the same , the variance not being sufficient to create doubt . That is to say , each of them saw appel- lant and the deceased fighting ; that appellant was the assailant ; that deceased had no weapon ; that appellant stabbed deceased three times in the nose, arm and left side ; that after appellant had stabbed deceased , he ran . Iverson Thompson stated that appellant had a conver- sation with him , in which he said his heart was not good , because when he returned home from the river he caught a man in his bedroom having carnal intercourse with his wife . Upon cross - examination , he said that appellant told him that the man he caught was the deceased ; that he , witness , asked deceased about the matter , and that he did not own or deny the charge , but simply smiled . This is the gist of what witness Thompson stated . Dr. H. C. Faulkner stated that he was called to examine one Dumah on the 4th of August ; that when he got there he found him dead , and the body was before a coroner's jury ; that he examined the body and found four flesh wounds , one on the forehead , one through the nose , penetrating the cavity of the nose in the right side , one on the back part of the shoulder , one under the arm between the 6th and 7th ribs ; that he carefully examined all these wounds , and one seemed to have been sufficient to cause death . He stated , upon cross -examination , that the instrument used , though not penetrating the heart , could in some cases cause death ; that in this instance it penetrated the heart . The substance of the evidence of C. D. B. King is to the effect that notwithstanding appellant promised not to sue the man for trespass upon him, because he did not wish to have him bring trouble on him for a woman , but would leave her , yet subse- quently , according to the evidence of other witnesses , three days having elapsed , he broke his promise and killed the man , or deceased . 474 The statement of Johnson , the witness for appellant , and the only witness , is not , in the opinion of this court , sufficient to overthrow the preponderance of the other evidence given by seven witnesses , and besides , in many instances he contradicts himself . In view of the evidence and law in the case , which this court has reviewed and studied , the court says none of the points in the bill of exceptions taken by appellant is sustained . The appeal simply breaks down for want of law and evidence to sustain it . ( Lib . Stat . p . 53 , sec . 27 ; II Bouv . Law Dict . under the heads of " Relevancy ," "Opinion ," "Verdict ," and "New Trial " ; I Greenleaf on Evidence , sec . 440 and note . ) To support the court's decree on the verdict , see II Bouv. Law Dict . under "Judgment " ; Lib . Stat. p . 69 , sec . 1 ; Lib . Criminal Code : "Murder ." It is therefore the opinion of this court that the judg- ment of the court below , based on a legal verdict and supported by law and evidence , is correct, and the court adjudges the same affirmed , and commands the said court to resume jurisdiction in the case and carry out its judgment . The clerk of this court is hereby ordered to send a mandate to the court below , to the effect of this judgment . E. A. MCAULEY , Appellant , vs. GUST LACKMAN , Agent for A. Woermann , Appellee . [ January Term , A. D. 1906. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . Debt . This appeal is from the proceedings and final judg- ment of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County , Judge William Wetherspoon pre- siding , and was rendered August , A. D. 1904. Accord- ing to the record filed in this court , this case was 475 originally entered and tried in the Court of Monthly Sessions , Sinoe County , over which His Honor B. J. Turner presides . The amount of debt demanded by the plaintiff in this action is one hundred and one dollars and fifty cents , which amount the defendant denies owing the plaintiff . The case was irregularly tried by that court , which rendered judgment that plaintiff recover from the defendant the one hundred and one dollars and fifty cents as sued for ; from which judgment the defendant took exceptions , and was granted an appeal to the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas at its ensuing session , the August term of said court of appeal , A. D. 1904. At the call of this case for hearing , both the plaintiff and defendant , having agreed thereto , submitted the case for trial without argument, and the court , after examining the facts in the case , rendered judgment to the effect that the testimony before it did not sustain the allegation of debt , and therefore the judgment sent up for review was erroneous ; and it dismissed the action with costs . To this judgment the plaintiff took exceptions , and was granted an appeal to this court , in order that this court might review the case , and determine what is law and justice in the premises . This case , being an appeal from the judgment of an appeal court , is an exception to the practice ; but since the right of such second appeal by a bill of exceptions has not been questioned by the party whose interest may thereby be effected , this court is not fully warranted in making further comment on the point . This court again reaffirms the doctrine well founded in the statute laws of this Republic , that "every person alleging the existence of a fact is bound to prove it" ; that "where a party charges another with a culpable omission or breach of duty , he shall be bound to prove it" ; and further , that the allegations of a party , however logically stated in the court of law , cannot be taken as 476 evidence . Proof to a judge , in the trial of a case, is what a compass is to a mariner on the ocean . In this case , Stephen A. Dunbar is the only witness introduced to prove the alleged debt , and he states as follows: "The defendant, Lackman , told me that he had requested the plaintiff ( now appellant ) to take with him to Monrovia one thousand dollars county checks and exchange same for general government bills , and that he and McAuley , the plaintiff , would not fall out ; that he knows of no special promise of the defendant to pay the plaintiff ten per cent commission on the dollar for so doing ; and that Lackman , the defendant, never admitted to him that he promised to pay the plaintiff ten per cent on the dollar , for exchanging said bills ." The above statement constitutes all of the testimony or evidence offered at the trial , except a bill of the plain- tiff where he charged for his services $ 101.50 . It is therefore not required that one should go beyond the statute laws of the Republic, to conclude that the facts stated in the plaintiff's complaint have not been proved , and that the judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions rendered in this case is erroneous . This court adjudges that the appeal be dismissed , and that the appellant pay all legal costs ; and the clerk of this court is hereby directed to notify in due form the judge of the court below , as to this ruling .
Selected judicial document
Begbah v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia