1 LLR 434
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 434. Source pages 434–439 (PDF pages 444–449). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1904.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
434 J. W. and C. R. HOUSTON , Active Partners of the firm of Houston Brothers & Company , Appel- lants , vs. FISCHER and LEMCKE , Dormant Partners of the firm of Houston Brothers & Com- pany, Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1904.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas, Montserrado County . Dissolution of Partnership . Pleadings-Bill of equity-Evidence . In order that a decree may be properly found, the allegations in a bill of equity must be supported by sufficient evidence . This case has had the greatest attention of this court , because of the intense feeling attending it from its com- mencement to the present moment, not only by those interested in its eventuation , but also by others . It is brought before this court upon an appeal taken under the statutes , against a decree of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County , December 31st , 1903 , sitting in equity to hear and deter- mine a bill or petition filed in equity by Fischer & Lemcke , dormant partners of the firm of Houston Brothers & Company , said bill praying a dissolution of the partnership of said firm ,- 1st, Because J. W. & C. R. Houston did , in violation of the articles of agreement upon which the partnership was formed , ship produce to Europe other than to the house of Fischer & Lemcke , partners as aforesaid of appellants . 2d , Because J. W. & C. R. Houston were indebted to them, Fischer & Lemcke , for a sum of over twenty -six thousand pounds . (Pounds sterling are here understood by the count .) The transcript of the record filed in this case supports the fact that the court , after hearing arguments pro and con , made the following decree : That the partnership be 435 provisionally dissolved and the business placed in the hands of receivers . This decree , in the opinion of this court , was a final decree and answered all that portion of the bill that a court of equity in upholding the peti- tion , could grant , hence from it an appeal would lie . The appellants , being dissatisfied with the proceedings and decree , appealed to this court in order that the doings of said equity court might be reviewed . Now in order that justice may be done in the premises and the rights of the litigants duly protected , this court felt bound to thoroughly inform itself of the articles of agreement upon which the partnership was formed . By a careful investigation of said articles we find the follow- ing facts : 1. That on the 15th day of August , A. D. 1898 , the appellants , J. W. & C. R. Houston of Monrovia , entered into a mercantile partnership with Messrs . Fischer & Lemcke of Germany , for mutual gain in pro- portions therein agreed to. 2. It was stipulated between the parties that the partnership should continue for five years , with the proviso that "should any of the members of the partner- ship wish to withdraw from the firm he should give other partners six months' notice ." We find further that on the 19th day of March , A. D. 1902 , by consent of all the parties, these articles of agreement were amended so as to read , "that in case of a desire on the part of Messrs . Fischer & Lemcke to withdraw from the firm during the lifetime of J. W. Houston and his brother , they would turn over the business to the Houston Brothers and allow them reasonable time to pay them off." Neither courts of law or equity make contracts for partners , but are authorized to interpret and give them effect from the intention of the parties making them . Having set this case in clear sunshine by removing from its surroundings all cloud and appendages , we now pro- ceed to notice the principles of law applicable to partner- ships. 436 "Where two or more persons combine their property , labor or skill for the transaction of business for their mutual gain , a partnership is created and is binding upon them . If the agreement does not contain a speci- fied time for the continuation of such partnership , it may be dissolved at the pleasure of either partner , but if there be such a provision it should be regarded bind- ing. However, against fraud and such like misconduct , and against unfair dealings, a court of equity may inter- fere and grant such relief as the nature of the case requires." The rule is generally laid down that an action between partners cannot be sustained in a court of law, but , "what a court of law cannot do , however , in this respect , a court of equity can ; and , generally , equity has a full jurisdiction over all disputes and claims between partners, and may do whatever is necessary to settle them in conformity with justice ." But although equity courts are clothed with extensive powers , yet they are bound by rules and practice , etc. , in the exer- cise of their authority . A fundamental rule of pleadings and practice is that evidence must support the allega- tions or averments in both law and equity proceedings . This court says that in pleadings , allegations are intended only to set forth in a clear and logical manner the points constituting the offence complained of, and if not sup- ported by evidence can in no case amount to proof. Evidence alone enables the court to pronounce with cer- tainty concerning the matter in dispute . After the most careful examination of this case we find no evidence , not the slightest , to support the allega- tions set forth in the bill of equity of the appellees. This court therefore adjudges , ( 1 ) that the court below erred in its decree that the partnership be provisionally dissolved and the business placed in the hands of receivers ; ( 2 ) that the court below did further err when it refused to dismiss the petition or bill in equity filed in this case , for the reason that it was indistinct and uncertain . The 437 bill being bad in part , should have been by said equity court adjudged bad as to the whole , and therefore dis- missed . Therefore the decree made in this case by the court below is hereby reversed and made void and of no effect , and the appellees shall pay all legal costs of the appeal . And the clerk of this court is hereby directed to issue a mandate to the court below as to this judgment ; also directing him to immediately place the partners as they were before said decree . J. G. MONTGOMERY , Appellant , vs. WILLIAM ZEISER , Agent for J. W. West , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1905. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County . Appearance-Imperfect judgment —Final judgment . A communication by a defendant's attorney addressed to the clerk of the trial court requesting him to enter an appearance , amounts to a formal appearance if made within the time fixed by law . Where the statute provides that upon rendering an imperfect judg- ment the court shall proceed to render final judgment , it is grossly irregular to proceed to trial without a jury. After rendition of a final judgment , a case cannot be reopened by the trial court and another judgment rendered , although in conformity with the previous judgment . This is an appeal from the ruling and judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County , at its December term , 1903. From the transcript of the record to this court , it appears that appellant did enter into a mercantile agreement with the appellee during the month of May , 1903 , to the effect that the appellee was to supply the appellant with goods or merchandise , thereby enabling him to open trade and exchange said goods for marketable African produce , and that the appellee did supply the goods as agreed . The record shows further , that the appellant on his part also promised and agreed to "deliver to the appellee all 438 marketable produce bought by him, at market price ." The appellant at the same time signed a note of hand for the goods thus delivered . Thus a business relation commenced May 15th , 1903 , and continued until Decem- ber , 1903 , when the appellee , plaintiff below , instituted this action of debt on the aforementioned note . The appellant insists that in liquidation of this note , he made several payments in produce ; while the appellee main- tains that on the note there have been no payments. Several receipts from appellee have been filed in this case, yet they are indefinite as to what account payment was made by the appellant , although given by the appellee since the execution of the note . This is briefly a synopsis of the case under review . At the call of this case for trial in the court below , the plaintiff, now appellee, offered and submitted to the court a motion urging that the appearance of the defendant , now the appellant , be struck from the record , on account of alleged informality, and that judgment be entered for the plaintiff ; which motion the court allowed , and immediately rendered imperfect judgment for the plaintiff . In effect this judgment precluded the defendant from maintaining any legal defence against the action, as is virtually maintained , that he was not in court . The form of the imperfect judgment is as follows : "The court adjudges that the plaintiff is , or is not entitled to recover." (Lib. Stat. Bk . 1 , p . 50 , sec. 7.) In this case , the record further supports the fact that the defendant below did , within the time allowed by law , file in the clerk's office of the court in which the case was entered , the following purported appearance : "J. R. Moore , Clerk of Court , Quarter Sessions and Com- mon Pleas Sir , You will please enter upon record that I have appeared this day to defend myself in the case West vs. J. G. Montgomery . Yours, J. G. Montgomery , by P. J. L. Brumskine , his attorney ." This instrument is dated Nov. 23d , 1903. By Stat. Book 1 , p . 22 , sec . 2, 439 the appearance of the defendant is to be accounted as when it is entered upon the record of the court . For this reason this court is of opinion that the court below greatly erred in ruling out the appearance of the appel- lant , it being a sufficient appearance in law . It must be clear to every unbiased mind that this act of the court destroyed every legal resistance that the appel- lant could have made against the suit. Again the record shows that after the court had ren- dered imperfect judgment , it allowed a trial without jury . This was also error in the court , because by statute , as soon as a perfect verdict is rendered , or an imperfect judgment completed , the court shall proceed to render final judgment . ( Stat. Book 1 , p . 52. ) The proceedings in this case for irregularity and illegality are without a parallel in the history of cases tried in any court in the Republic . We mention one more of the irregularities attending the trial below . On the ninth day of January , 1903 , the court rendered final judgment , thus putting an end to the suit unless an appeal was taken . Now jurisdic- tion could not be resumed without an order from a higher court . Yet, on the eleventh , two days after the rendition of the final judgment , the court reopened the case , examined witnesses and rendered a judgment , although in conformity with the previous judgment . For these errors and illegalities attending the trial of this case below , and with a view that justice be done to the litigants , this case is hereby remanded to the court from which it came , for trial de novo , costs to follow , until its final settlement . And the clerk of this court is hereby directed to issue and cause to be served on the judge of the Court of Quarter Sessions , Grand Bassa County , a mandate after the usual form , informing him of this decision .
Selected judicial document
Houston et als. v. Fischer et al
Supreme Court of Liberia