1 LLR 359
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 359. Source pages 359–366 (PDF pages 369–376). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1900. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
359 FAH SOCHO , Appellant, vs. REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1900. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Murder. Justifiable and excusable homicide-Plea of self-defence-Manslaughter . In prosecution for murder in the first degree , the State to convict must prove beyond a rational doubt that the killing was wilful and that it was done from malice, expressed or implied . So where deceased met prisoner and suddenly assaulted him with a club and then drew from his pocket a pistol , and prisoner struck in self -defence , which blow produced death ; it was held that the killing was murder in the second degree , technically termed manslaughter. It was further held that a party assailed need not wait until he is disabled by his assailant before striking in self-defence ; that while he is bound to use all means within his power consistent with his safety to escape from his assailant, yet if he is assaulted with a weapon that could produce death or great bodily harm and he is put in peril of life or limb , he may justify the stroke under the plea of self -defence , and if death results from the stroke it will amount to murder in the second degree . In this case the appellant Fah Socho is charged with having committed the crime of murder , which is the highest offence of which one may be charged in the cata- logue of crimes ; a crime punishable in all ages , by both human and divine laws , with death ; a crime the very mention of which causes humanity , however degraded , to recoil . The record from the court below shows that at the September term of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County , A. D. 1899 , Fah Socho , the prisoner ( appellant in this court ) , was indicted by the grand inquest of the aforesaid county, for the wilful and felonious murder of one Walter F. Smith , on the twenty -second day of July , 1899 , in the settle- ment of Bensonville , in the County of Montserrado , to which indictment the appellant was held to answer , and put upon trial for his life before a jury consisting of 360 twelve of his peers , duly sworn to hear, try , and deter- mine the facts . Witnesses were introduced and sworn , and deposed . The testimony having been concluded , the charge and evidence were in due form submitted to the jury by the court , with instruction to try the facts and return their verdict accordingly . The jury , after delib- eration , made up and presented to the court a verdict of "guilty" against the prisoner , now the appellant before this court . The appellant , being dissatisfied with the verdict thus rendered , motioned the court below for a new trial , maintaining that the verdict was contrary to the law , the facts , and legal instructions of the court , and that the evidence supported a verdict of homicide in self -defence ; which motion the court below did not allow, and subse- quently rendered judgment of death , the sentence of the law attached to the crime of murder . To this ruling and final judgment of the court the appellant excepted , and appealed to this court for a review of the cause . Before noticing the testimony rendered in this case and the law controlling it , this court says : "Murder is defined to be the wilful killing of a human being , with malice aforethought , either expressed or implied by law, and to constitute the offence there must be , first , sound mind and memory in the agent ; second , an actual kill- ing; third , malice expressed or implied . Manslaughter is the unlawful killing of another , without malice either expressed or implied ; as in mutual combat on a sudden affray or fight in which malice is presumed to be want- ing ; hence such killing is reduced to murder in the second degree , technically known as manslaughter . This court further says : Homicide in self-defence is bound within the limits hereinafter described . To justify the taking of life in self -defence the party must employ all means within his power , consistent with his safety , to avoid the danger and avert the necessity . He is not, however , compelled to wait until he is rendered unable 361 to protect himself , by reason of great bodily harm , or even to turn his back upon his assailant . If he is in imminent peril and can reasonably conclude that his assailant intends to take his life , which he may conclude by the means employed in the assault ,-as , for instance , the employing of a dirk , an axe , a hatchet , sword , cut- lass , hoe , gun, pistol , spear , or like weapons , the use of which is likely to produce death or great bodily harm ,— under such peril he may strike in self-defence , and if killing be the result of such stroke , the killing would be in self - defence . The meaning of the law is clear . The assailant must be in possession of some deadly weapon , and he must make such demonstration as would put the assailed in the peril of his life , or in danger of receiving great bodily injury , or put him on guard to protect his house against a burglar , or against one who entered to commit rape or other felonious acts ; otherwise the law will not allow the plea of self- defence . Having pointed out in a concise manner the law con- trolling this and similar cases , we now proceed to the consideration of the testimony. It may not be amiss for us to say that evidence is that which demonstrates and puts in clear light the truth or falsehood of any accusation . Referring to the testimony in this case , we discover that Walter F. Smith , the person killed , had staying with him a native heathen girl , in whom he manifested uncommon interest . This girl was taken from his custody by legal process and put in care of Sheriff Stubblefield , so as to be forthcoming at the ensu- ing meeting of the Quarterly Court , Montserrado County , to give evidence in a prosecution instituted and con- ducted against the said Walter F. Smith for a high mis- demeanor . That by some means Smith found out that Fah Socho , the prisoner , and this girl had agreed upon marriage . That Smith soon after saw the prisoner and told him what he heard about his intention to marry the girl , and that if he did so he intended to kill him . 362 That shortly after this the prisoner was on his way to Monrovia , when Smith saw him and with a gun in his hand ran him a considerable distance , and that the prisoner for safety took refuge in the forest, where he was hidden from Smith . That the prisoner uttered his complaint to the Sheriff , to the County Attorney , and lastly to a Justice of the Peace , for legal process to restrain Smith , which for some cause was not afforded him . That after this the prisoner was heard to say that if Smith attacked him again he intended to defend him- self by killing him with his sword (pointing to a sword he usually wore ) . The evidence further shows that during the month of July , 1899 , (the facts above stated occurred during the month of June ) -that on the 22nd day of July , as aforesaid , the prisoner Fah Socho was passing through the settlement of Bensonville , when and where he met Smith , and that Smith charged him with shaking his sword at him. (This , however , was not seen by any of the witnesses present . ) That the prisoner had on or wore the sword he usually traveled with . That Smith and the prisoner met in close contact , Smith's advancing soon bringing them together . That as soon as near enough Smith struck prisoner with a large coffee stick, and made at him two or more other blows with said stick, which blows the prisoner avoided by fending . That the prisoner up to this time made no blows at Smith whatever , but firmly faced him , warding off each assault . That Smith then drew from his pocket a revolver , when the prisoner jumped back and struck Smith with his sword , from which blow, he , Smith , shortly after died . This is a synopsis of the testimony sent with other record before this court for review . To us this is clearly a case wherein homicide may be said to have been com- mitted in self -defence . The revolver , a deadly weapon , being drawn by Smith in the engagement , reasonably put the prisoner in imminent peril of his life , and both 363 reason and instinct impelled him to strike in defence of his life . A new trial , therefore , should have been granted by the court below. This court adjudges that the verdict returned in this case is contrary to the law and the evidence , and the same is therefore set aside ; that the judgment rendered on said verdict is hereby reversed , set aside , and rendered null and void ; that the prisoner Fah Socho be discharged from prison by order of the judge of the court below , as soon as he is informed in chambers of the ruling and judgment of this court ; and that the clerk of this court issue in due form a mandate to the judge of the court below , as to this judgment . T. T. BREWER , Appellant, vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1900. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Maryland County . Misdemeanor . Indictment-Formal requisites of a valid indictment. 1. A motion in arrest of judgment will be sustained where the in- dictment is defective in material parts . 2. In a trial upon an indictment which was found not to contain a distinct and certain averment as to the place where the offence was committed and the specific title of the offence charged , it was held that the indictment was bad and that a motion in arrest of judgment should have been granted. This is a case in which the Grand Jury of Maryland County indicted appellant , T. T. Brewer , for making an aggravated assault with attempt to shoot with a loaded revolver one R. T. Ellis , Deputy Sheriff of said County , between the first and thirtieth days of April , A. D. 1899 , and who was arrested and tried by the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Maryland County , at its August term , A. D. 1899. The said appellant , being convicted of the offence by the jury, considered that 364 substantial justice had not been meted out to him, whereupon he motioned the court below for arrest of judgment , for the following reasons as laid in said motion : First , "That the indictment is insufficient , vague and uncertain , obscure and indistinct , in that it does not set forth with certainty the place where the crime with which he is charged was committed ." Second , "That the in- dictment should be so framed as to give a certainty as to the nature of the crime or misdemeanor of which he is charged ." The court below not sustaining appellant's motion for arrest of judgment , he , the appellant , then submitted his exceptions to the rulings of the court , embodying the points raised in his motion , together with exceptions to the verdict of the jury , as being contrary to the law and evidence in the case ; also , to the judgment of the court , upon the ground that according to the wording of the judgment , in his opinion , it does not emanate from any court, but simply from the "Judicial Department , August term , A. D. 1899 ," which does not correspond with the indictment upon which he was arraigned ; and also , that the judgment inflicts a punishment for felony and not for misdemeanor . The case is therefore brought up to this highest Court of Appeal , upon the said exceptions , by the appellant , for review . The court will now proceed to consider the indictment , ruling, judgment and evidence in the case , and to give its opinion on the same. Bouvier defines an indictment to be "a written accusa- tion against one or more persons for a crime or mis- demeanor , presented to and preferred upon oath or affirmation by a grand jury legally convoked ," and he lays down as the essential requisites of a valid indict- ment, first , that the indictment be presented to some court having jurisdiction of the offence stated therein ; secondly, that it appear to have been found by the grand jury of the proper county or district ; thirdly , that the 365 indictment be a true bill and signed by the foreman of the grand jury ; fourthly, that it be founded with suffi- cient certainty . For this purpose the charge must con- tain a description of the crime or misdemeanor of which the defendant is accused , and a statement of the facts by which it is constituted , so as to identify the accusation , etc. The formal requisites are , first, the venue , which at common law should always be laid in the county where the offence has been committed , although the charge be in its nature transitory , as a battery, etc. (Bouv . Law Dict. Vol . 1 , p . 789 , under the head " Indictment ;" Blackstone Com. Book 4, pp . 306 , 307. ) Now, then , on examination of the record in the said case , the court finds that the indictment of the grand jury is defective in two essential points, namely , in that it is not framed with sufficient certainty, and that the charge does not contain a certain description of the mis- demeanor of which the defendant, now appellant , is accused and a statement of the facts by which it is con- stituted , so as to identify the accusation . The general statement , "an aggravated assault with attempt to shoot ," is not sufficient to constitute the crime or mis- demeanor, since it does not convey to the mind the nature of the offence in law. It is the opinion of this court , therefore , that the court below erred in refusing defendant , now appellant , an arrest of judgment . "Any want of sufficient cer- tainty in the indictment (as in the statement of place , where material ) of the person against whom the offence was committed , or of the facts and circumstances con- stituting the offence , or otherwise , which is not aided by the verdict , is a ground for arresting the judgment . In criminal cases an arrest of judgment is founded on exceptions to the indictment . ( Bouv . Law Dict . Vol . 1 , p . 185 : "Arrest of Judgment .") And further , there is manifest error in the ruling of the court below , where it assigned as a reason for refusing 366 to sustain the motion of the appellant for arrest of judg- ment that "to admit an arrest of judgment would further work corruption in the Judiciary Department ;" seeing that in the opinion of this court the motion for arrest of judgment was within the scope of the law and supported by its spirit and meaning . This court is also of the opinion that the judgment of the court below should not be affirmed , for the reason that it inflicts a punish- ment not compatible with law and justice in such cases made and provided , for the Constitution of Liberia declares that " excessive bail shall not be required , nor excessive fines imposed , nor excessive punishment in- flicted ." In this instance the punishment was a fine of fifty dollars , disfranchisement , and imprisonment in chains for two weeks with hard labor , which the court says is suitable to crimes and not to a misdemeanor . The court further says that the court below erred in rendering said judgment , for the reason that the ver- dict of the jury was manifestly out of accord with the evidence in the case , which evidence shows conclusively that the appellant acted in self-defence against the said R. T. Ellis . For the above reasons this court adjudges that the judgment of the court below is reversed . The clerk of this court is hereby ordered to issue a mandate to the judge of the court below , to the effect of this judgment .
Selected judicial document
Socho v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia