1 LLR 305
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 305. Source pages 305–308 (PDF pages 315–318). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1897.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
305 PRINCE POPO, Appellant, vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1897.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . False Imprisonment . A motion in arrest of judgment for legal defects upon the face of an indictment may be made before the rendition of final judgment whether a demurrer was previously made or not ; a defective indictment on mate- rial points is not aided by the verdict , as in civil suits the declaration might be . This case is an appeal from the several rulings and final judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County , in the above case . In the bill of exceptions the appellant thinks the court below erred in not sustaining the motion in arrest of judgment . From the record this court discovers that the Grand Jury for Montserrado County , at the June term of said court , A. D. 1896 , indicted one Prince Popo for false imprisonment , and after a verdict of guilty was rendered against the prisoner , a new trial was prayed for by the prisoner's attorney and denied by the judge of the court below . The prisoner then motioned for an arrest of judgment and in said motion disclosed his real line of defence , which was for insufficiency in stating the time in the indictment . The ruling of the court below on the motion states that the time is not the essence of the offence , and therefore immaterial . It is much to be regretted that the learned judge stopped so short and did not proceed with his research from the same authority , i. e., Blackstone's Commen- taries . That honored authority says : "But when he , the prisoner , appears in person either for a capital or inferior conviction , he may at this period , as well as at his arraignment , offer any exception to the indictment , 306 in arrest of judgment , as for want of sufficient certainty in setting forth either the person , the time , the place , or the offence , and therefore a defective indictment is not aided by a verdict as defective pleadings are in civil cases ." In examining the evidence for the State this court finds that none of the State's witnesses gave any date or even an approximate date when the offence is said to have been committed . In all democratic governments the rights and liberties of citizens should be respected with scrupulous certainty . We do not mean the license of the noble called liberty , but the liberty we inherit from our Magna Charta , i. e., the provisions bequeathed to us by our fathers in the entire second section of the Bill of Rights . Therefore this court is of opinion that the court erred in not sus- taining the motion in arrest of judgment . It is therefore the judgment of this court that the judgment of the court below be reversed ; and further , it is ordered that the clerk of this court issue a mandate to the court below to the effect of this judgment . DAVID D. FREEMAN , Appellant , vs. THE REPUB- LIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1897.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Stealing Money from Post Letter Bag . 1. The statute relating to the responsibility and punishment of postmasters for neglect of duty and breach of trust comprehends car- riers in the postal service as well ; a common carrier in the postal service is answerable to the State for any unfaithful performance of the trust imposed in him . 2. Flight is in itself an offence against the law and carries with it great presumption of guilt ; it will subject a party to forfeiture even where the accusation which produced it is not proven and the party not condemned . In this case this court finds a labored effort put for- ward in an endeavor to show that neither the statute law 307 nor the notes in Blackstone's Commentaries apply to gov- ern us in this country . It is maintained that the Liberian statute law on page 164 , section 9 , is only applicable to offences committed by postmasters . It has also been asserted with great earnestness that the witness , Mrs. D. E. Sherman , said that she knew nothing about post- ing a certain letter and registering same on or about the 2nd of March last . But by reference to the record this court finds that the witness D. E. Sherman , in answering a question of the county attorney , gives this statement : "I did send such a letter to the post -office March 2nd , of which I hold a copy." Ques. "Was said letter posted ?" Ans.-"It was ." "Did you get a receipt for same ?" "I did." "Was the letter registered ?" "It was ." This court does not find it necessary to give any expres- sion on the notes in Blackstone's Commentaries at this time in addition to what was said by this court in the case of Sarah Ann Roberts against Jane Rose Roberts (ejectment ) in January , 1878 . The statute laws of Liberia furnish sufficient data and authority for the elucidation and final disposing of this case . It would be absurdity for this court to think or believe that the Legislature intended to punish the post- master only for betraying his trust by breaking the seal or making away with any letter , paper or package addressed to another person . The appellant seems to have been employed as a common carrier, connected to and with the post - office , and as such he is answerable to the State for any unfaith- ful performance of the trust imposed upon him . If that is not the meaning of the law then any member of this community could secretly purloin a letter , or even a paper or package from the post -office , and should he be detected , flagrante debito, yet the postmaster alone would be responsible . The motive of the State in allowing this case to occupy so much of the court's time, thought and study, is an 308 enigma up to the present . Mr. Blackstone in his fourth book, page 387 , uses the very striking words : "For flight also on an accusation of treason , felony , or even petit larceny , whether the person be found guilty or acquitted , if the jury find flight the party shall forfeit his goods and chattels ." The very flight is an offence carrying with it strong presumption of guilt and is at least an endeavor to elude and stifle the course prescribed by the law. From the authority of the Liberian Statutes and the legal principle to be deduced , this court decides that the prisoner David D. Freeman has been rightly convicted , from the statement of facts in this case , and that the judge below did not err in refusing to grant a new trial . Further , the clerk of this court is required to make known the judgment of this court to the court below ; and appellant is ordered to pay all costs.
Selected judicial document
Popo v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia