1 LLR 239
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 239. Source pages 239–246 (PDF pages 249–256). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1892. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
239 THOMAS GEORGE , Appellant , vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1892. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Murder . Where a party unlawfully carries about a loaded gun and from care- lessness and neglectfulness a human being is killed or injured , the act is not regarded in law as an accident and therefore excusable , but is punishable according to the magnitude of the offence . The law forbids all persons from carrying about their bodies or persons any dangerous weapon whatever , to the terror of the good people of any community , and will not lend any aid to such a one . In this case the appellant pleads that the act of killing Bak - o00 was an accident , and that he took him for a monkey . But it must be remembered that accident is something over which a person has no control , as , for example , if the gun he had in his hand was loaded , but not cocked at all , and by some influence or power unknown to him , upon the gun , it fired off and killed the said Bak - oo , it might more reasonably be regarded as an accident , and there- fore excusable ; but the act of having about us a loaded gun is a public offence in itself , and it is rendered more criminal when it is cocked , aimed and fired upon the body of a " reasonable being " who , from the force , con- tents and effect of such loaded gun , dies . Looking at the appellant's act from this standpoint , you will readily see that the deceased died from the appellant's volun- tary and deliberate act , for it was he who cocked the gun , took the aim and fired the gun ; it was therefore not an accident , hence the result of his act presents evidence of malice which the law implies . Now the jury , being the judges of the credibility of the evidence , they having the opportunity of noticing the manner in which the statements were given by the witness , were prepared to decide the facts in the case . 240 Notwithstanding some irregularities had been pointed out by appellant's attorney , yet the court below , in pursuing the course to justice , has been able to so instruct the jury as to enable them to come to a proper conclusion . Therefore this court adjudges that the judg- ment of the court below is affirmed , and that the clerk of this court inform the court below of the doings of this court . T. A. JOHNS , Plaintiff in Error, vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Defendant in Error . [January Term , A. D. 1892. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Assault with Intent to Kill . Until verdict is rendered in open court the jury should be kept together and should not converse with any person except their fellows upon the case submitted to them. It is necessary to a valid verdict that the finding be unanimous and the conclusions voluntary ; where threats or other influence have been employed by one juryman to induce another to agree with him , it is good ground for awarding a new trial , and where a new trial under such circumstances has been refused , the appellate jurisdiction will correct the error of the lower judge by revers- ing judgment . This case presents two points into which all others presented in the assignment of errors must fall . Before coming to the points submitted for this court to deter- mine, we deem it proper to say that in the trial of criminal cases the jury empanelled to try the facts should be kept together from the time they are em- panelled until they have rendered in open court their verdict . And it would be a reprehensible offence in them to converse with any one except their fellow jurors , touching the case handed to them, and it is also official misconduct in any constable or other officer attending them to so act and speak as to influence their verdict . The statute laws of this Republic provide that a jury must be composed of twelve men ( this refers to the petit 241 jury) , and that the consent of the whole number is neces- sary to a verdict . So tender are the laws of Liberia as to the life , limb , liberty and property of citizens , that they forbid the taking away of any of the inalienable rights except by verdict of a jury or the laws of the land . It is obvious to the most prejudiced mind that within the meaning of the statute laws of this Republic the conclusion of less than the entire twelve jurors cannot be taken for a verdict . This case comes up upon a writ of error against the rulings and judgment of the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , at its Decem- ber term , 1891. We find assigned as one of the errors , that said court during the trial of the plaintiff in error , who was held upon the indictment of the grand jury to answer the offence of an assault to commit murder , received and rendered judgment against plaintiff in error, upon what was handed into the court as the ver- dict of the jury , sworn to try the facts , notwithstanding one or more jurors (the jury being polled ) disavowed said verdict as his conviction of the truth of the case ; stating to the judge , as the record shows , that from fear of beating or other ill treatment threatened him by the other jurymen with him on the case , he only consented . Upon this the plaintiff in error moved that the verdict be set aside and a new trial awarded . This motion the court overruled and proceeded to render sentence of fine and imprisonment . This court says that the verdict upon which the judg- ment is founded being unlawful , the judgment rendered thereon must likewise partake of its unlawful nature . The court did err in not granting the new trial prayed for by the plaintiff in error and such new trial would have been warranted in law . It appears further that the plaintiff in error then and there motioned the said court for an appeal , which motion the court also overruled , assuming the idea that 242 under the Statute Laws of this Republic, in criminal cases there can be no appeal taken to the Supreme Court. This idea is without foundation in the laws of the Republic of Liberia and in this ruling the court below did also err . This case terminating on the law, we now proceed to the rendition of the judgment of this court as the law dictates . This court adjudges that the judgment in this case in the court below be and is hereby reversed and made void and shall have no legal effect whatever ; and the clerk of this court is now commanded to issue a mandate informing the lower court of this court's action in the premises . VARNE , VOMBO , GINDA and MOMORA SINGBY , Appellants , vs. REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1893.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Misdemeanor . The appellate court will not take cognizance of any matter of law to which the attention of the lower court does not appear to have been called. Where an irregularity in the process and returns was not brought to the notice of the court of inferior jurisdiction , the appellate court will not entertain a motion bearing thereon . This case comes up before us upon a bill of exceptions taken to the rulings and judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions of Montserrado County at its June session , A. D. 1891. At the call of this case the appellants , through counsel , submitted for the consideration of this court a motion in arrest of judgment . The said motion embraces the following points : That the bonds of the appellants and the writ of arrest do not appear upon the record of this case . The court on inspection of the entire record in this case , takes occasion to say that not only the rule of 243 practice , but the law, requires that in all appeals taken to this court by bills of exceptions the questions of law relied upon must be raised in the court having original jurisdiction over the case . The record in this case nowhere shows wherein the attention of the court below has been called to any irregularity in either the service of the writ or the return thereon as raised in the appel- lants ' motion. The statute of the Republic regulating appeals is emphatic in language : "The court to which the appeal may be taken shall examine the matter in dispute upon the record only ; it shall receive no addi- tional evidence , and shall reverse no judgment , for any defect of form , or for any matter to which the attention of the court below shall not appear to have been called , either by some bill of exceptions or other parts of the record ." In observation of this positive statute the court adjudges that the appeal is dismissed . JOE FARROW , Appellant, vs. M. T. DECORSEY , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1893. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Certiorari . Writ of habeas corpus-Constitutional law . Legislative enactments cannot repeal or annul constitutional provis- ions. Justices of the Supreme Court and other courts of law of this State , have an inherent right to issue writs of habeas corpus ; the con- stitutional power of the Supreme Court or any of its justices in matters of habeas corpus, cannot be annulled by Legislative enactment . The hearing of the cause of imprisonment or other restraint of one's per- sonal liberty upon a habeas corpus by a justice of the Supreme Court , is in the exercise of appellate jurisdiction and in consonance with the judicial powers conferred by the Constitution ; a statute denying this right can have no binding effect , because of its conflict with the provis- ions of the Constitution on this point. This is a case in which, upon the application of Joe Farrow , in a matter of habeas corpus before the Court of 244 Monthly and Probate Sessions , Montserrado County , a writ of certiorari was issued and served upon Hon . John F. Dennis , Judge of the Monthly and Probate Sessions for the County of Montserrado , removing said case to this court . The writ of habeas corpus issued by Judge Dennis , answering its office , sought to remove from imprisonment two boys , in order that the judge might inquire into the lawfulness of their confinement . The writ of habeas corpus is a high privilege writ , and was so understood by the framers of the Constitution , the denial of which must soon endanger personal liberty , so sacred to the people of this Republic ; the refusal of this high writ would soon become the parent of despotism and leave the people's liberty to the caprice of those vested with authority ; and too soon the deformed head of Anarchy would rise up , and with great political upheavals , shake our beloved Republic to its very founda- tion . We premise that one of the great timbers em- ployed by the venerable fathers in constructing the framework of our political fabric , is supported by a buttress of liberty to be found in the 20th section of the Constitution of Liberia , which speaks the following lan- guage :" All persons shall be bailable by sufficient security unless for capital offences where the proof is evident or presumption great , and the privilege and the benefit of the writ of habeas corpus shall be enjoyed in this Repub- lic in the most free , easy , cheap , expeditious and ample manner , and shall not be suspended by the Legislature except upon the most urgent and pressing occasion , and for a limited time not exceeding twelve months ." ( Vide Const . Liberia , p . 10 , sec . 20. ) The Legislature of the State has the undoubted right to repeal or suspend its laws , but not Constitutional provisions except in manner provided in the Constitu- tion , because all laws should be in harmonious keeping with the spirit and intention of the Constitution . Neither have they the right to restrain judges in the exercise of 245 Constitutional rights . The issue of a writ of habeas corpus is an inherent right of the judges of the Supreme Court and other courts of law of this State , agreeable to the genius of the Constitution of the Republic of Liberia , and its issue and hearing is in the exercise of appellate as well as original jurisdiction . The question whether the individual shall be im- prisoned is always distinct from the question whether he shall be convicted or acquitted of the charge on which he is to be tried , and these questions may be decided in different courts . The decision that the indi- vidual shall be imprisoned must always precede the application for the writ of habeas corpus . The statute recognizes three distinct courts of this Republic : first , the Monthly and Probate Court ; second , the Courts of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas ; and third , the Supreme Court ; all of which courts consist of a judge or judges , a clerk and a seal ; the clerk to record their doings and the seal to render the same authentic . This court need not therefore say that all of these courts are in their organization constituted Courts of Record , and clothed with distinct and concurrent jurisdiction . The inferior courts of this Republic are vested with both appellate and original jurisdiction , to destroy which is to destroy the very purpose for which said courts were constituted . The Supreme Court, says the Constitution , shall exercise original jurisdiction in cases affecting Am- bassadors or other public ministers and counsels and those cases in which a County is a part . In all other cases it shall exercise appellate jurisdiction . From the foregoing , it is clear to the mind of this court that judges , in hearing the cause of imprisonment of an individual committed to jail or otherwise restrained of his liberty , act solely in the exercise of the appellate jurisdiction conferred by the Constitution ; and those of the Supreme Court especially . Therefore any act of the Legislature which tends to withhold from any of the 246 courts of this Republic or any judge thereof the exercise of his inherent right , is in conflict with the fundamental and paramount law of the State and is therefore of no binding effect . This court further says a writ of cer- tiorari is a writ of relief , authorized by law, and is con- trolled in its application by the same . This writ removes the proceedings of a court of inferior jurisdiction to one of superior , and is employed when their proceedings are not in harmony with laws and justice ; but it should not be prayed for until the final judgment or determination of the court in which a case is tried . It is clear to the mind of the court , and it must be to the minds of all parties concerned , that to remove a case for review before the final judgment of the court in which it had been entered , is premature . It is needless to enlarge upon a point so fully established by settled principles. of law and known by the learned counsels engaged in this suit . It is the final judgment of a court that puts an end to the dispute between litigant parties , and so long as the main question which it was one of the objects of a suit to determine remains undetermined , a certiorari would not lie . In this case the removal was during the examination of witnesses , hence against law and the practice of courts. The case is therefore remanded to be tried over in the Court of Monthly and Probate Sessions , Montserrado County , where it was pending , and the clerk of this court is hereby commanded , under the rules , to issue the proper mandate to the said court to the effect of this ruling .
Selected judicial document
George v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia