1 LLR 225
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 225. Source pages 225–227 (PDF pages 235–237). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1889. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
225 E. A. L. MCAULEY , Appellant , vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1889. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . Forgery . When this case was called for hearing , during the reading of the record sent up from the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , at its August term , A. D. 1888 , Attorney General Davis , representing the Republic of Liberia , asked the court permission to speak , when he addressed the court as follows :- "The Attorney General declines to defend this case because the indictment charges that the appellant com- mitted forgery by altering the figures on a due bill for $6.75 , given him by one Gussefield , and which is set out in the indictment ; but all the evidence goes to prove that the figures altered were no part of the original due bill , but were a part of the credit endorsed on the due bill , and such item of credit is not mentioned in the indictment , and therefore , I think the evidence does not sustain the allegations in the indictment sufficiently for me to make a defence in the case." The foregoing declaration of the Attorney General is an abandonment of the case , on the part of the Republic of Liberia (appellee ) . A similar declaration was made before this court in February , A. D. 1878 , by Attorney General J. W. Hilton , in the case of Republic of Liberia against F. J. Payne and Hester Huff, and the premises upon which the abandonment was based , and a few of the important legal principles involved in that case the court briefly reviewed . We would do likewise if any peculiar feature of this case required it. In the face of a formal abandonment of a cause , such as we have cited above , we have only to render judg- 226 ment; therefore this court adjudges that the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions in and for the County of Sinoe, rendered against E. A. L. McAuley at its August term , A. D. 1888 , is reversed , under the 4th section of the 33d rule of the Revised Rules of this court , and the clerk of this court is hereby commanded to forthwith transmit a mandate to the aforenamed Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Ses- sions , Sinoe County , to the effect of this judgment . WM . M. ROBERTS , Appellant , vs. THE REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1890. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . Misdemeanor . Postmaster-Revenue officer - Jurisdiction of the Court of Admiralty in suits against postmasters for fraud . 1. Indictment brought against a postmaster for fraud is cognizable before a court of common law . 3. The selling of postal stamps by a postmaster for his own account is not in itself unlawful ; there must be proof that they are the property of the Government to constitute fraud upon the revenue . This cause came on for hearing upon an appeal from the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions of the County of Sinoe , and was argued by counsel . Upon inspection of the record it appears that appellant (prisoner below ) motioned the court below to dismiss the cause for want of jurisdiction , alleging that he , being indicted as a revenue officer , should be held to answer in the Court of Admiralty and not at common law. The court below overruled the motion , giving as its opinion that under the Statute Laws of Liberia the postmaster is not a revenue officer . From this ruling and final judgment of the lower court the prisoner appealed . We are of opinion that the court erred in saying that "under the Statute Laws of Liberia the postmaster is 227 not a revenue officer ;" for the postmaster and post -office establishments were created by the statute for the purpose of revenue and public convenience . But he is not such an officer in the sense of the general accep- tation of the term "revenue ," so as to take him out of the jurisdiction of a court of common law in which cases of this kind are cognizable . It was alleged in the indictment in the court below , that "the prisoner sold Liberian postal stamps and unlawfully converted the proceeds to his own use," but it does not appear in the transcript of the record that those Liberian postal stamps were the property of the Government of Liberia , or any person or persons other than the prisoner who sold them. The charge of misdemeanor in the indictment is a grave one and was preferred by the State as a fact, and under the Statute Laws of Liberia the State was bound to prove the existence of that fact ; but we cannot find upon the record sent here a single testimony tending to prove the allegation . Selling postal stamps is not unlaw- ful , unless it can be proved that such stamps are not the property of the vendor , and that he , she or they are unlawfully in possession of such property ; for stamps are often sold from the post -office to individuals in large quantities . It was the duty of the State in the court below , to prove that the postal stamps sold by Wm . M. Roberts , ex- postmaster for Sinoe , the proceeds of which he converted to his own use , were the property of the Repub- lic of Liberia , so as to establish the alleged misdemeanor . Considering the allegation and the evidence in the court below we are of the opinion that the charge was not sustained , and the prisoner should have been acquitted . This court adjudges that the judgment of the court below is reversed . The clerk of this court is hereby commanded to send down to the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions for Sinoe County a mandate to this effect .
Selected judicial document
McAuley v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia