1 LLR 220
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 220. Source pages 220–221 (PDF pages 230–231). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1888. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
220 A. D. WILLIAMS ( Surviving Partner ) , Appellant , vs. R. LEWIS & CO. , Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1888. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Debt . 1. Objections to written evidence should be made at the time it is offered ; where a document has been admitted in evidence it is error in the judge not to allow it to be submitted to the jury. 2. A verdict in debt should show the amount due by the one to the other without reference ; but where the jury cannot agree upon the debt the judge may by statute ascertain the same . This case has come up from the Court of Quarter Ses- sions , Montserrado County , upon a bill of exceptions to the ruling and judgment of said court at its March term , 1887 . The first point raised in the bill of exceptions is , to the jury refusing to consider the items in defendant's schedule of additional credits . In this connection , on a careful inspection of the records of this case , we dis- cover also that a book ( of the defendant below ) con- taining accounts the nature of which were to serve as a set - off to the plaintiff's demand , was admitted by the court as written evidence in this case . The same having been admitted , this court fails to see legal cause why it was not submitted to the jury . Just here we would remark that objections to written evidence should be made before it is admitted by the court , and at the time offered . It is clear to the mind of this court that the admitted evidence , if it had been considered , would have aided the jury in coming to a just conclusion with respect to the debt due (if any ). It further appears from the record , that the case thus submitted and considered by the jury resulted in the following verdict : - Jury room , Monrovia , March 3rd , 1887 . We the jurors to whom the case was submitted , R. Lewis & Co. , vs. A. D. Williams and Brother , do agree that A. D. Williams is entitled to the credit 221 of the coffee , palm kernels , and bedstead , according to evidence produced in the case , and after the amount of these articles is subtracted from the principal , A. D. Williams & Bro . are entitled to pay the balance . A. B. HARRIS , Clerk . THOMAS CURD , Foreman . We are of opinion that this verdict is vague and uncer- tain , in that it does not fix or ascertain the debt in ques- tion. A verdict in debt should show without reference , the amount due by the one to the other. The statute only authorizes the judge to ascertain the debt when the jury disagrees , and only in such cases the judge would be warranted to insert the amount. But in this case he asserted or ascertained the debt , a power not given him in law . For the debt was a ques- tion of fact which the judge could not determine unless in the manner referred to above . A disagreement of the jury is nowhere to be found in the record of the proceedings in this case . For these palpable violations of the principles of law surrounding this case , we are compelled to say, that on account of the mixed questions of law and fact not legally disposed of by the court below , it does not appear by the record for which party the judgment should have been given . This case is therefore remanded to the Court of Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , to be tried de novo , costs to follow .
Selected judicial document
Williams v. Lewis et al
Supreme Court of Liberia