1 LLR 215
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 215. Source pages 215–216 (PDF pages 225–226). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1888.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
215 SIMON ATTIA , Appellant , vs. JOSEPH H. SUM- MERVILLE , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1888.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County . Trespass vi et armis . Trespass vi et armis-Action of damages —Written directions in pleadings. 1. Where the statute provides a remedy for a wrong or injury, its provisions take precedence over the common law rule and must be strictly followed . The statutory remedy for a trespass vi et armis upon the person or property is an action of damages . 2. The written directions of the plaintiff or his attorney to the clerk of court , is his authority for issuing process against the defendant , and it should contain every essential instruction to the clerk with reference thereto. This action was brought and tried in the Court of Quarter Sessions , Grand Bassa County , at its March term , 1887 , in which court a verdict was obtained award- ing the plaintiff below the sum of five hundred dollars damages. The court rendered judgment confirming said verdict . From the ruling and proceedings of the court during the trial , as well as from the judgment rendered , the defendant took exceptions , upon which exceptions the case is brought up to this tribunal for review . This case has claimed much of the attention of this court, as it presents several important issues not before raised and submitted to it for its decision . The sole question in the case is the appellee's right to maintain the action brought , the right to do which is disputed by the appellant ; this point having been argued with great labor and talent by both parties . The court will address itself to such points in the bill of exceptions as may be required to enable it to arrive at a just conclusion . The first objection set up in the bill of exceptions is, that the action of trespass vi et armis cannot be main- tained for the injury complained of in the declaration , because the statute provides a distinct and sufficient 216 remedy to be called an action of damages , and the remedy under the statute could not be set aside for that of the common law. The legal determination of this question by the court below would have ended the controversy . This objection , however , was not allowed by the court below . In this the court did err , because the statute constitutes the paramount law of the land , and could not be set aside by the common law, however analogous its mean- ing . To the second plea raised in the appellant's bill of exceptions , we remark that in respect to the written direction we are of opinion that it should set forth every necessary instruction of the plaintiff to the clerk of the particular court in which the case is entered . The legal existence of the writ depends solely upon a proper written direction . Therefore the court did err in overruling the objection set up against the written direction of the defendant below . The next point claiming this court's attention raised in the bill of exceptions is that the court below did err in submitting the case to a jury under the aforementioned circumstances . This objection is well founded , because the first plea set up in the answer of the defendant below should have been determined in his favor , hence the court did err in submitting the facts to the determination of the jury , the case becoming a nullity because of the legal defects mentioned in said plea . After the most deliberate consideration , this court is unanimously of opinion that the judgment should have been given for the defendant below . Therefore , this court adjudges the judgment of the court below in this case is reversed , with costs .
Selected judicial document
Attia v. Summerville
Supreme Court of Liberia