1 LLR 17
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 17. Source pages 17–25 (PDF pages 27–35). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1862. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
17 PETER DAVIS , Plaintiff in Error , vs. REPUBLIC of LIBERIA, Defendant in Error. [January Term , A. D. 1862. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Treason- Native inhabitants . It is undoubtedly a fact that our native inhabitants , under treaty stipulations , which treaties are laws when confirmed by the Legisla- ture , are bona fide subjects of this state , and the political authority of the same covers them in all of their relations . The peculiar situation of the natives , in their mode of living , their depth of ignorance and their incapacity to understand the workings of civilized governments , made it necessary to draw their connection and acknowledgment of our political rule over them in form of treaties , but not to be misconstrued that the whole law of the land is not binding upon them, and that they are not to have the benefit of it when arraigned under it, for crime committed . The native inhabitants of the country are capable of committing treasons against the State. In reviewing the case of one Peter Davis , a native subject of this Republic , brought up to this court upon a writ of error , several features present themselves which are important to speak of, as the charge for which he was condemned in the Superior Court is one of high magnitude . The execution of the law of the land ought to be understood to be done according to its letter and intent, and not to be misconstrued to meet the circumstances sur- rounding it , but to affect the circumstances as brought in contact with said laws . It is well for the judiciary to under- stand , as well as the whole people, whether they be rightful franchised citizens , or such of its inhabitants as are held as subjects , over whom extends the sovereign and political jurisdiction of the authority of the government. It is un- doubtedly a fact that our native inhabitants , under treaty stipulations , which treaties are laws when con- firmed by the Legislature , are bona fide subjects of this state , and the political authority of the same covers them in all of their relations . The peculiar situation of the natives in their mode of living , their depth of igno- 18 rance and their incapability to understand the workings of civilized governments , made it necessary to draw their connection and acknowledgment of our political rule over them by forms of treaties , but not to be miscon- strued that the whole law of the land is not binding upon them , and that they are not to have the benefit of it when they are arraigned under it for crime committed . To speak of the records as a whole might be done with propriety , but as the error is simply a question of law founded upon treason , it is well to say that our native inhabitants are capable of committing treason . The treaties and laws extending over their political , as well as sovereign jurisdiction , and they being answerable to this government alone , and this government answerable for their acts toward foreigners , constitute them a part and parcel of the people of this Republic, and they, being such , would make any act of theirs in concert with the enemies of this government with whom it may be con- tending , treason . If the people against whom this man was contending were not in treaty with this govern- ment, and they were waging a war against the govern- ment and he aided them , it would be treason . But , as we have been informed , both parties owe an alleg- iance to this government, and as such they entered into an uproar which resulted in a riot . A riot, being usually the act of a large number of persons , is otherwise de- scribed as a tumultuous disturbance of the peace by persons assembling together of their own author- ity (which this man and people have done ) with an intent mutually to assist one another against any one who may oppose them in the execution of some enter- prise of a private nature , and afterwards actually exe- cuting the same , in a violent and turbulent manner, to the terror of the people of the town , whether the act intended was of itself lawful or unlawful . The act of the man now a prisoner apparently par- took of this feature . It may be considered that they 19 can rebel , as others might do living under the same Constitution and laws, to prevent its due execution , or put themselves up in defiance of the lawful authority preventing the course of government. All this may be repelled by force of arms by government, when milder proceedings cease to prove to be a virtue . But treason , that highest of all crimes, can only be committed by an attempt , by conspiracy or otherwise, to destroy the gov- ernment , by giving aid and comfort to its enemies to accomplish it . "Treason , to betray : the attempting to overthrow the government of the state to which the offender owes an allegiance , or of betraying the state into the hands of a foreign power .' "" In England , treason is an offence particularly directed against the person of the sovereign , " in carrying war against the King in his realm , in adhering to the King's enemies ." In the United States the definition of treason is fixed by the Constitution , it being declared to consist only in levying war against the United States or the adhering to their enemies giving them aid and comfort . (Burrill , part 2 , page 996. ) Such is the law of Liberia , as the laws of both countries in criminal cases have been adopted by this country . The fact attempted to be proved against the prisoner falls short of the law, and the crime he has committed , being only a misdemeanor of a high character , has been unfortunately magni- fied to be treason , and thereby supported by the court , which would, if allowed to stand upon such a construc- tion , hazard the liberties of the people. In finding this conclusion , the court holds that our native subjects have of right the privilege of a trial by jury, and the law of the land ; but in all cases they must be allowed the full bene- fit thereof , as the law guarantees , and not deprive them of right the privilege of a trial by jury , and the law of the under the panoply of the law . The court is of the opinion that the prisoner , from the records , has com- mitted a crime against the peace of this Republic , and 20 the indictment endeavored to show it, and the court to support it, to be treason . This court declares that he has not committed treason , but this crime is in the nature of high misdemeanor, for which he is responsible to the laws and government of the land . ― As the laws of the Republic make it obligatory on this court to reverse or affirm all cases coming before it on appeal or otherwise , and award such decisions as in its opinion it may deem best , or to remand , as the case may be , therefore , the court de- crees that the finding of the jury and court below constituting the crime of Peter Davis treason , is erron- eous , and the same is hereby reversed ; and that he , Peter Davis , be considered as committing a misdemeanor , partaking of an armed riot against other subjects of this Republic . It is further decreed that all fines and for- feitures imposed on said Peter Davis , and under which he stands committed , are hereby annulled . Also that the said Peter Davis be and he hereby stands committed , to be disposed of by the executive of the country , according to the spirit of an act supplementary to an act entitled , " An act to maintain peace and enforce order on the highways to the interior ," passed 1859 , page 53 , sec . 4 . C. B. DUNBAR , Appellant , vs. A. E. McGILL , Appellee . [ January Term , A. D. 1863. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Criminal Law . Crim . Con . Removing the hearsay evidence , the opinion given as evidence , the contradiction of witnesses in their state- ments , together with circumstances surrounding the whole case , the conviction of the court is that there is nothing to convict the parties of criminal conversation . It is , then , the opinion of the court that Charles B. Dunbar and Angelina E. McGill in accordance with law 21 and evidence are not guilty of criminal conversation . Therefore , it is hereby decreed that the verdict of the jury and the judgment of the Court of Montserrado County in this suit be and hereby is reversed , with its effects and liabilities ; and that judgment is hereby given in favor of the appellant in this case ; and that a man- date is hereby ordered to be issued to the court below , directing that its verdict and judgment are null and void , with costs in this court . WHITE & WHITE , Appellants , vs. JOHN MOORE and others , Appellees . [ January Term , A. D. 1863. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Sheriff's Sale . The court , after a careful review of the documents in the above case , as well as the judgment of the court below , have concluded that the proceedings of the court in 1843 is genuine , and that the action of the sheriff by selling said property was in accordance with law , and hence the deed is valid , and the parties are in rightful possession of the property . Therefore , it is hereby de- creed that the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas of Montserrado County be and the same is hereby confirmed , with costs in this suit . DAILY vs. DOE . [ January Term , A. D. 1864. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Writ of Error - Practice . The court is of opinion that as the legality of the writ was not made a point in the declaration , it could not be made a question in the case . Therefore , if the search . warrant was illegal in any of its features the plaintiff in error should not be made to suffer while pursuing a 22 proper course , which was confined by his oath and legal- ized by the warrant of law . The law, by all means , authorized the magistrate to act within the precincts of the court in which he resides . It does not appear that the magistrate committed any error by the issue of the warrant , and the constable in acting could only perform his duty by the authority embraced in the warrant , as an officer of search . The court is also of the opinion that the law guarantees the right to individuals to cover any and all places by a warrant in which he may have suspicion that his prop- erty is concealed , and the warrant under oath is the security . The law in the statute , page 10 , section 49 , declares if the writ shall have been improperly obtained , the law would give a remedy at law against the party procuring the writ , but if properly obtained , no action can lie ; then if a writ is obtained in a proper form and by the requirement of law by the party seeking it , he is secured against all actions. The oath of the party , the designation of the place or places , as well as the property , is the form proper , and if the magistrate confines himself within his jurisdiction , that is, the county in which he and the party reside , he will also be considered to be in form . In all these relations this court is of the opinion that the appellant and Justice of the Peace have confined themselves to law and form . Therefore the decision of this court is that this case be and is hereby reversed , and that the appellee in error be ruled to pay all costs. DAILY vs. CAREY . [January Term , A. D. 1864. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Injunction . A review of the case of Daily vs. Carey on injunction has presented to the court such features as would lead this court to place it in such a position as that both parties may have the benefit of the common law. 23 It could not be considered just under the conflicting circumstances and the manner in which the case was tried, that a final adjudication be had in the premises . The question and matter itself in all its bearing appears to be mixed , hence it is highly proper that an oppor- tunity be afforded for an unravelling of the several issues by the proper authority . The design of the law and its restrictions is to remedy evil , and allow every person full and adequate opportunity to prove and maintain whatever right he or they may regard as hav- ing been suppressed , or about to be , by any person or persons . The power and authority of the court to issue and perpetuate the injunction cannot be questioned . But that the court should bind or keep bound such parties , that have been arrested by its mandate when the matter could have been adjusted at common law , does not appear to be correct . The law is created to ensure peace and good will between all men whom it superin- tends , but to construe it so as to keep parties in an unsettled condition , is not what the law intends . The court should always follow the proper remedy , and allow each party , by law and opportunity , to prove or dispose his claim . There is no dispute as to the deci- sion of the court below , as regards the incompetency of said court at Marshall to try and determine a case involving an amount more than thirty dollars , and it is duly confirmed by this court . It would have been proper , however , for the Court of Pleas to have had the case before it in such a form as to render both parties com- petent to defend themselves with such facilities as may have been convenient to them . The court is of opinion that as the case was not tried by the court below , but only checked indefinitely , which if continued would prove injurious and unsat- isfactory to those concerned , it is hereby ordered that the injunction shall be so dissolved as to allow the parties to enter their claims at common law , in such 24 courts as may have jurisdiction to try and determine such cases ; also that the relief from the pressure of the injunction shall not enable the party having the benefit in the Provisional Court to follow the decision of said court . The case is hereby remanded to the Court of Quarter Sessions to be disposed of as directed by this decision , and a mandate and a true copy of this decision is hereby directed to the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions of Montserrado County . J. D. JOHNSON vs. H. R. W. JOHNSON . [January Term , A. D. 1864.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Certiorari-Injunction to Stay Execution . The court has no need to enter into any elaborate argument respecting this case coming before it on a writ of certiorari . The writ , of course , is an important one , and founded upon the intent of the law to give full justice to all alike . This writ is no stretch of jurisprudence , but one among its instruments to set forth its magnitude and majesty . The injunction issued by the Court of Common Pleas , Montserrado County , to stay the execution of its own order and final judgment , was and is , in the opinion of this tribunal , erroneous , though the motive might have been pure . The only remedy , if a remedy was needed , would have been an appeal from the decision of the court ; and also if the law officers had gone beyond their limits , and done any act against the defendant which was unlawful and for which they had no warrant from the court , they would be responsible for all such unlaw- ful proceedings if any injury ensued . The law carries with it great power where defiance is practised , but on the other hand it is reasonable where responsibilities make it expedient. It is admitted that the successful party has the right to demand an execution on the rendi- 25 tion of final judgment , because it is his right in law , and to justify this course there are several reasons which the court deem unnecessary to allude to here . But it does seem that equity would suggest that the successful party , in an extreme case , allow his antagonist time to meet his obligations to him ; but this would only be done by securing the plaintiff with proper safeguards . The court is a mighty organ and any person who is clothed with its prerogatives has in a very large degree the care and pro- tection of all living under its influence.Therefore , the court may be said to have discretionary powers in par- ticular cases to defend one and secure the other . The law never contemplated violence , only when vio- lently assailed , and no person has the right to violate the law , or in other words obstruct it in its legitimate pur- suits . The appellee in this case apparently makes the same plea here as he would have done before the Court of Pleas on the injunction , that is , the requirement of time , to meet a demand which he admits to be just , and which the court below confirms by its judgment . Hence there seems to be no question as to the righteousness of the cause . Equity would suggest time , provided the appellee give such security as may satisfy the appellant in this cause . This court is fully of the opinion that the whole case should be divested of obstructions , since the rendition of judgment was final . The costs of the court below being one of the principal features of objection . which led to the application for the injunction , the court will here note and here direct that so much of the case as relates to the costs be remanded to the Court of Pleas , Montserrado County , for its adjustment to the extent as it may appear lawful to the court . Therefore it is hereby decreed that the full force and restraint of the injunction in the case of J. D. Johnson vs. H. R. W. Johnson is dissolved , and the case rest upon the final judgment and order of the court as delivered on record before this court , with all costs in this court ,
Selected judicial document
Davis v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia